Jalapeno Popper Grilled Cheese

“Jalapeno Popper” Grilled Cheese (Homemade)

With today’s sandwich, I wanted to recreate the flavors of a jalapeno popper, that bar-food staple appetizer. In the restaurant version, jalapeno peppers are stuffed with cream cheese, battered, and deep fried. It’s a perfectly spicy, creamy accompaniment to, say, a dozen pints of beer. I felt like a direct translation of jalapeno poppers into grilled cheese form would be a little too mild, though, so I made some substitutions. The crunch of the bread, the creamy, lightly tart chevre, the salty bacon, the spicy jalapeno, and the sweet tang of the apricot jam all balance each other perfectly, into a sandwich that has almost every type of flavor happening all at once, confusing your mouth and warming your belly. It’s intensely rich and satisfying, and I want you to make one. Here’s how it goes:

“Jalapeno Popper” Grilled Cheese
Makes one giant sandwich, serves two


  • 2 slices sourdough bread
  • 2 ounces chevre
  • 4 slices crisp-fried bacon
  • 3 whole fresh jalapeno peppers
  • 1 tablespoon apricot preserves
  • 2 tablespoons butter


Slice each jalapeno in half lengthwise, and remove stem, ribs and seeds. Place cut-side-down on a baking sheet, and broil until skins blacken and blister, about five minutes. Remove jalapenos from broiler, and transfer immediately into a plastic bag or other sealed container. Seal and let steam until cool enough to handle, about 10-20 minutes. Remove blackened skins by pinching them between your thumb and forefinger, and discard.

Spread one of the slices of bread with the chevre. Top with roasted jalapeno peppers, then bacon. Spread the other piece of bread with the apricot preserves, and add to sandwich. Butter each side of the sandwich, and toast in saucepan over medium heat until bread is toasted, about 2-3 minutes a side.


  1. Stephanie says

    This sounds like a marriage made in heaven , you are a saint – thank you! Off to the shops…

  2. says

    Apricot jam, hmm? I make something a bit like this (but with black beans and without bacon). It never occurred to me to try a sweet spread, but it makes perfect sense as a foil to the spicy peppers and creamy cheese. I’ll give it a whirl!

  3. Amanda says

    Made this for dinner tonight. I’m a self proclaimed grilled cheese junkie. LOVED this recipe. Ahhh-mazing!

  4. Stephanie says

    This is a winner! I had a few hiccups, as living in Australia now I am dealing with a different style of bacon and sourdough, and fresh jalepenos are a rarity. I’m wondering if you used spreadable chevre…or maybe I should have had mine room temperature (of course in the end it matters not). So, I removed the “Canadian bacon” end of the long rasher and fried up the bacon “tails”, and used a comination of roasted long red chilies and jalepenos from a jar. Aussies are big on apricots so that was no worries. The bread was sliced a bit thin (should have done it myself), and you had to close your eyes and think of Otis Redding to imagine it as real sourdough, but boy, in the end the Jalepeno Popper was a little ripper!

    • Malcolm says

      We used regular chevre, but brought to room temperature before assembling the sandwich. I’m happy to hear you soldiered on and found a way to make this work, Stephanie. It sounds like your “bacon” solution may have been even better than ours!

  5. Jessica says

    These were delicious! I couldn’t find chevre, so I researched possible substitutes and ended up using feta, which was great! My husband said they could be a little spicier, but I loved them!

    • Malcolm says

      Glad to hear it! You can control their spice levels by leaving more of the ribs and seeds in the jalapenos. Roasting them also softens their heat; you could always try them raw, but I like the texture of the roasted version.

  6. says

    The sandwich sounds great. I have six jalapeño plants growing in my garden. I can’t wait for the first peppers so that I can recreate your sandwich.

  7. Heather Malotke says

    We made these for lunch today and they were a big hit. My 12 year old son says, “We are WAY making those again!” :) I also shared the link on Facebook, where a lot of people are waiting to hear how our lunch turned out. Thanks for the great recipe.

  8. Laurie Cron says

    We made these last night….WOW! It is going to be very difficult to make as an occasional treat because it was so delicious. Thank you for sharing the recipe.


  1. […] 1. To Make the Sassy Jezebel Sauce: In a mixing bowl, beat apple jelly with an electric mixer; add in the pineapple preserves, peach preserves, and orange marmalade. Mix thoroughly. Whisk in the drained horseradish and dry mustard. Add in the pepper. Place in glass jars and cover; keep in cold in the refrigerator until ready to use (makes about 4 pints of sauce and keeps for about 2-3 weeks).2. To Assemble the Sandwich: On all of the slices, slather on 1T of Sassy Jezebel Sauce. On the designated bottom slices start layering with the creamy Boursin cheese, fire-roasted jalapenos, crispy thick bacon, and then sharp cheddar cheese. Top with the other slice of bread and compact the sandwich together slightly.3. To Bread the Sandwich: Set up a battering station by using 3 pie tins. For the first station, mix together the flour and seasonings. For the second station, whisk together the eggs, buttermilk, and hot sauce. For the third station, pour the contents of the panko breadcrumbs. Now, dredge the sandwiches completely in the flour mixture and then shake off the excess. Next, dunk the sandwiches into the egg wash, and then finally cover the sandwiches in the panko breadcrumbs.4. To Cook the Sandwich: Fry the sandwiches in a sauté pan with oil on high heat until crispy and golden brown. Finish the sandwiches in the oven (about 400 degrees) to make sure the sandwich is heated through completely.5. Remove from the oven and then slice the sandwich in half. Serve and enjoy!*Also, if you have not heard about Jezebel Sauce, it is a sauce made of preserves and horseradish that is very popular in the South. It is most popularly served over a block of cream cheese as an appetizer. I know it may sound bizarre, but it is actually really good. This recipe, which I found my mother’s recipe box, makes a HUGE batch, but it is great to make and put into mason jars, and then you can have something on hand if a visitor decides to show up unannounced. You can always make a small batch of the sauce, using the same ingredients to your liking of course!! source: jalapeno popper sandwich.  […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *